Holy Cow
| Category: | Ice Cream Shop |
| Address: | 7270 S Broadway # 1, Red Hook, NY 12571, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-758-5959 |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 29
BA
Barbara Larrimore
Please if you have anyone in your life touched by a food allergy do not go here! I brought my two year old son there on Sunday, with a big group of people and my older children. My son has a dairy allergy and cannot have ice cream, but loves sprinkles. When I went to order I asked if I could please have sprinkles on the side and I would pay extra for them. The answer was no, because that was their policy. I explained that my son was allergic and would really love some sprinkles. The answer was still no, but the girl said that " I can put the sprinkles on the ice cream and you can shake it onto your hand". I kindly explained that again, my son has a milk allergy and if the sprinkles touched the ice cream, he could not eat it. I offered to buy another whole ice cream, if they would just please put the sprinkles on the side. They said no. I asked to speak to a manager, they said there was no manager, and that I could call the owner at the store when she is in. They left me with the final words "We cant make everyone happy". I cannot believe, that there was absolutely no empathy for a child. A complaint has been filed with the Americans with Disabilities Act, and I will never go back there ever again! I never understood these issues until I became a mother of a child with food allergies, but trust me when I say a little bit of kindness and empathy would have gone along way.
AN
Annamarie Fagnani
Ive only heard of places like this where Im from! Holy Cow is one of my favorite stores here in Red Hook! The employees are always kind and smiling. Even thought they wont put jimmies(I tried to pay extra. They wont do it, but were so kind about it.) on the pre made cakes in the tall standing case. The flavors and toppings are delicious and come in a large variety to find or create your own favorite! Prices are 100% acceptable for the great quality of the product. Customer service is excellent and the older woman who I often see in there and usually assist me (by chance)is a master of making cones! Id suggest Holy Cow to anyone looking for desserts. CASH ONLY.
JA
Jared Tennant
This is a really interesting location in that its very small town feeling, but given the location it would be. Cash only in this place, which Id incredulous annoying considering its 2016 and I can go the store and flying camera drone. The ridiculously good ice cream here makes up for that huge misstep but Id definitely give this place five stars if theyd tidy up the place just a bit and and didnt seem so standoffish when taking my ice cream order. Other than that if youre the area, Id definitely go here for ice cream. Just make sure you have cash on you though!
CH
Cheryl DuBois
Barbara Larrimore, if your child has a dairy allergy, you should understand that any product at the Holy Cow could have been cross-contaminated with dairy. Had they served your son just the sprinkles, he could have had a reaction due to cross contamination. You clearly understand this as you rejected brushing the sprinkles off a cone. Holy Cow staff acted appropriately and possibly save your child a trip to the hospital.
EU
Eugenia Karydas
Is there anyone who has come within a 30 mile radius who doesnt know about this place? Best soft ice cream anywhere; great prices Been coming here more then 2 decades! First thing our house guests ask for. Theres never a wrong season to enjoy it! Even Apres skiing. We finally figured out how to bring ice cream cakes or quarts of the soft ice cream home to Queens with out melting!
TH
Thelong Lunarnote
Asked for a Coffee Milkshake and saw the girl fill the cup with soft serve and coffee syrup (yuck). I asked her to stop and please make it from the coffee ice cream in the case and was told that they didnt make shakes with hard packed ice cream. I left without the shake. Are they kidding me? Big disappointment.
CA
Cathryn Nichols
I absolutely love holy cow ice cream. Its always so fresh and creamy, and the staff is always so nice. The best ice cream shop around. I live in hyde park and will travel to red hook just for their ice cream!
VE
Vera Ewing
A wide variety of products available in soft or hard ice cream. Eat at picnic tables outside or take a treat, pint, or ice cream cake home for later. Great price. Fast, friendly service. Cash only.
CO
Cory Silvernail
Maybe I go there a little too much... But that is because they have such amazing ice cream at good prices. Im addicted and I go there more than twice a week (although I shouldnt)
DA
Daniel Timperio
The most popular ice cream shop in the area. Even when the line is out the door its only a short wait and the ice cream is well worth it! Outdoor seating and kid friendly.
TH
Thomas Quackenbush
The best, cheapest ice cream you will find. All the people who work there are amazing and sweet. It is a must visit if you are in the area. Open year round, cash only.
RO
Rory Hertzfeld-Hearse
Super popular! I recommend a stop when in the area. Sit outside. They have an amazing informational board posted with honest Native American History.
GE
George Doscher
Fresh made Ice Cream. This is the best Ice Cream in all of Upstate NY. There is almost always a line so be prepared to wait. Super friendly staff.
A
A Private User
I think it is the best place ever togo with your family thats what i do also with my cousins From: cynthia :) I go there every 2 weekeds in a month
SA
Salvatore Furino
I drive 30 minutes from Poughkeepsie just to get the ice cream here and its worth every second of it. Just wished they offered waffle cones.
DE
Dennis Griffin
Best ice cream in the area. Great prices. Friendly, courteous service. Long line at peak times but moves amazingly quickly. Fantastic place.
CO
Corwin Kave
The best soft serve. Hands down. If Im within an hour radius its an automatic stop. But they stopped topping my soft serve with peanuts
SA
Sawyer Stippa
The dont take cards, though thats probably how they keep is so cheap. If youre willing to wait on summer lines youll be very happy.
A
A Private User
Not only is Holy Cow the greatest ice cream ever, but its affodable , i travel all the way from Hyde Park just for this ice cream,
A
A Private User
Holy Cow is fabulous. Their ice cream is delicious and you cant beat their prices. They dont skimp on size or toppings either.
MA
Matthew Adams
Awesome homemade ice cream! People in the area will drive up to an hour to visit. A great stop after visiting the Aerodrome.
SA
Sam Zapadinsky
You know its good when most of the time there is a line out the door! Great family hangout and very affordable ice cream.
AN
Antone DeVoe
Best soft-serve this side of the Divide. A local product by locals (As opposed to corperatios) from local farmers.
JO
John Mc
Very Hoping Ice cream place. Very busy. great tasting ice cream. Bring only cash, they dont take credit cards.
?
エスコバルカルロス
はじめまして でもアイスクリームはとてもおいしい
LA
Laura Hayes
Consistently delicious fresh made ice cream and other frozen treats every time. Affordable prices too!
RY
Ryan Kotler
Pretty great, farm-style ice cream joint. Try the blueberry pie or black raspberry hard ice creams.
AB
Abe Deshotel
Best freaking ice cream. The blueberry pie ice cream is incredible. I dont even like blueberry pie.
DA
Dave Kuhhorn
I ABSOLUTELY loved holy cow nice workers and I hope to come back for the best icecream EVER !!!!!
35 most recent searches
Other organizations
Photos
Photos of comments
