Central Pastry Shop

Reviews 41

AS

Ashley Gierzak

Ruined our wedding cake. Our wedding was in March, and I was so furious I made a promise I wouldnt write a review till I had calmed down. But everytime I look at our wedding photos Im reminded of the Hack job that was our wedding cakes. All I wanted was a cake with white icing. no trim. no stupid hand drawn swirls, yet I got a cake with purple trim and white swirls. I ordered (paid extra) for a grooms cake with sugar printing on top, what we got was a bright yellow cake with a hand stenciled batman logo. It looked like a child made it, and it certainly didnt work for a grooms cake. I was at our wedding calling to complain about the cake. Granted they brought us out a corrected cake, but took the crappy one? The owner was rude to me and told me that was what I had ordered when I paid extra for the sugar sheet. Our sheet cake looked fine. But I cant get over the round that is in all of our pictures, I could have designed it better...and all I wanted was a good tasting cake with white icing so we could put our own flowers in. Side not their decorating skills are stuck in the 80s. while the cakes are delicious the look awful for anything other than a retirement party. If the owner would fess up when they were wrong and make of an effort to treat her customers well then this could have been avoided.

---

MA

Makayla Burrows

well first, to start off, the lady on the phone was amazing. very helpful. I did not know any prices and she was happy to help. Second, I needed a cake tuesday and I called monday 5 minutes before they closed and ordered a cake. Very pleased with my cake. It was amazing. It tasted just as good as it looked. My cake was less than $20 and it was so much worth it. I honestly wouldve paid triple that price for the quality I got. And last, they close at 5:30 and I didnt get to the bakery until 5:30 if not later. I called in advance to let them know id be late, they were very friendly and more than happy to unlock the doors for me to come pay and pick it up. Bless them all and I will definitely be going back for more!!

---

NI

nick maxey

Not only did Central Pastry offer me the worst service I have ever experienced I also recieved a cake that looked like it was made by a 5yr old. Fortunately for me the cake was a "test" cake that was to resemble my wedding cake and Central Pastry made it a very easy decision to have the wedding cake made somewhere else. READER: If you would like a doughnut or a muffin maybe its a decent place to go but if you would like something real made do yourself a favor and find another place to go. CENTRAL PASTRY: Do your business a favor and hire a professional who is experienced in decorating cakes. (not just sponge bob cakes)

---

MA

Mary StJohn

The baker created the most beautiful 50th anniversary cake Ive seen. She asked for details about the wedding, and tailored the cake to my answers. The white roses, gold leaves, and gold sparkles plus icing in the style of 1962 cakes formed a truly lovely display. The hostess of our party actually suggested we wait to cut it until the next day so we could enjoy it longer (we vetoed the suggestion & enjoyed the cake). Both cake & icing were delicious. Thank you Central Pastry!!

---

A

A Private User

Best bakery I have ever been to. The cake is legendary but they have everything, truly a very creative full line bakery. Prices are very reasonable considering everything is from scratch and of extremely high quality. They are courteous and have plenty of on-site parking. We stop in every time we are in the area and have them ship to us fairly often.

---

CA

Carla Fee Homsher

Cant say enough about Vera and her staff at Central Pastry! Everything is absolutely delicious and the buttercream icing is out of this world! Be sure to try a fudge square! A section of chocolate cake with a huge swirl of vanilla buttercream icing on top and covered in chocolate ganache! Love this place!

---

DO

Don R

This is the only place that you should ever go to get a birthday cake. I have been eating cakes from here for more than 40 years and they have always been outstanding. Everyone should at least give this place one try and they will understand why I feel that it is the best.

---

DA

Dawn Conner

I contacted this place over a week ago for a quote on a Dinosaur birthday cake, today 3/6/17 they say they still have not got my emails or texts of the pictures. What a joke I could had went someplace else by now, thanks a lot for wasting my time!!

---

SU

SUE HOBGOOD

Great service. Good food. Great price I called last minute and they came through. Cake s are delicious we get one every year for anniversary and kid birthdays. Well worth the trip. 5 ***** bakery.

---

HE

Heather Bryant

This is a family owned pastry shop that makes the tastiest goodies daily. They also do cakes to order and have them ready to go along with pies too. Stop in you wont be sorry!

---

B

B Brockman

Best cakes in town and the pumpkin donuts are spectacular- a seasonal favorite in our house! We also love the cinnamon bread. Friendly & courteous service.

---

GR

Greg Williams

Donuts were good, staff was very friendly. Its nice that theres off street parking (around back). Coffee was terrible, so get your coffee elsewhere.

---

ER

Erin Waltz

This place is amazing. I could have eaten everything there but the strawberry chiffon cake was amazing. Make sure you get a piece when you go.

---

HE

Heather Garitson

I grew up, a few blocks from here. I love this place. Loved waking up, to the smell, of their fresh cakes and donuts! Nothing better!

---

LI

Lisa Jacobs

Some of my best childhood memories were going there with my dad. I now take my kids there. Great place good pastry.

---

BR

Brian Yount

Delicious donuts and pastries. So glad we were told about this place. Love the little squares of heaven!!!! Yum!!!!

---

CH

Charles Rucker

Have the best donuts in Middletown no doubt about it and hands down and they have pretty good cake too

---

BR

Britt Dunning

I got a cookie here during our stop on the donut trail. The rest of the food also looked delicious!

---

AD

adrienne smith

Best cinnamon and sugar twist doughnuts!! You must call ahead if you hope to get some!

---

RO

Roger Mays

Super nice lady who was there. Bought a cream horn just like I remember as a boy.

---

CA

Cathy Mahoney

I have been going there since I was little!! I love their pastries!!!

---

TA

Tara Swallow

Donuts are always fresh and well made and the employees are very nice

---

CH

Chris Lewis

Wonderful donuts and bread, and even better people! Thank you!

---

SH

Sharon Grooms

BEST CREAM HORNS. Well worth the cost. Everything delicious.

---

MI

Michael Soule

Good doughnuts, but not very friendly at 7 in the morning

---

RH

Rhonda Davis

Best cakes, cream horns, cupcakes, everything is great...

---

CR

Crystal Mckeehan

Yummy pastries. A little too sweet for my taste.

---

TH

The Real Panic

This place is baller. Their donuts are amazing.

---

BE

Ben Koch

Best pumpkin crunch donuts. Simply amazing.

---

CH

chris starr

Great donuts. Awesome friendly staff.

---

MA

Matthew Hall

Favorite Shop Bought Cake Icing!

---

BA

Bandele El amin

Good donuts and friendly people.

---

MA

maxx punkistador

best business in all of M-town

---

JA

james collier

Great cakes and pastries!

---

MA

Marie Picklesimer

Best donuts around!

---

KR

Kristine Harrison

Greatest of sweets

---

AS

Ashley Crain

Always delicious!

---

JE

Jerry Gabbard

Mmmmm Donuts...

---

TH

The Wolf

Taste amazing

---

CH

Christi Littleton

Good pastry

---

DY

Dylan Mitchell

Amazing

---

---