A Cake In Time

Category:	Cake Shop
Address:	29 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA
Phone:	+1 631-553-8824
Site:	acakeintime.com
Rating:	4.3
Working:	8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM

Location

Photos 14

Reviews 9

Taryn Tsien

Sherry is an absolute pleasure to work with! From design to delivery, her service is exceptional! She blows me away every time. I have ordered seven cakes from her over the years...and I just placed an order for another! We are always looking for an occasion so we can order one of her masterpieces. The cake that I ordered from her in July for my wedding reception was a gorgeous stunner! It was more beautiful than I could have imagined - her intricate stenciling and hand painted details on the cake made it the talk of the night! On top of the gorgeous looking cakes, they also taste delicious!

R PM

The cake was ok, but it arrived 30 mins after the event started!!! It was supposed to be delivered between 11:00 am and 12:00 pm, the day before Sherry said she might arrive there closer to 12:30pm because of the number of deliveries she had which was ok. The cake was actually delivered at 2:30 pm just after the time we had allocated to get pictures taken and the excuse was that there was too much traffic which is expected on a Saturday with beautiful Spring weather. They should have planned accordingly and offer much more than returning ONLY HALF of the delivery fee for messing up.

Alisa Oliver

I drove from the bronx for my grandsons birthday cake very long ride but it was well worth it!! It was the snoopy and Charlie Brown cake red velvet with oreo filling it was soooo good the best cake I have tasted so far I got so many compliments about this cake. Also the staff was very professional and sweet so thank you sherry great job I will be purchasing many more cakes from you !

Brianna Pompa

Our cake was perfect! Sherry was great at keeping us in the loop about our cake! It was exactly what we expected. We had a two teir cake with vanilla, chocolate and chocolate buttercream. It was savory and sweet. A lot of care and detail went into our cake. We were very pleased with the finished product. Well definitely be ordering from A Cake In Time again.

Nicole Tyte

I ordered a cake for my nieces baby shower. I found a picture of a cake on pinterest and emailed it to Sherry. She made a cake that was even better than the picture I sent to her. The cake was absolutely beautiful and it tasted delicious too. Everyone at the shower commented on the cake. I wouldnt use anyone else for my next event.

Barbara Johnston

Love this gem of a shop right in our home town! Very easy to work with, listened to our ideas and made suggestions that were spot on for a cake that represented our party theme. Design was perfect, and our guests raved about the quality, taste and freshness. I highly recommend this shop and will certainly be returning.

Jessica Lucero

She did my cake for my sweet 16 and it was delicious and she actually took tha time to sit down with u and get what u wanted not what she had or what she wanted it was all about u and what u wanted and she was so sweet and it over all it was amazing.

Jitu Prajapati

jitu bhai rshoya

Shaughnessy McKenna-Dusling

Amazing flavor and incredible design talent. Best cake around!