Stedman Cafe

Category:	Cafe
Address:	6335 Magnolia-Stedman Rd, Mayville, NY 14757, USA
Phone:	+1 716-789-5047
Site:	stedmancafe.com
Rating:	4.6
Working:	7AM–2PM 7AM–2PM 7AM–2PM 7AM–2PM 7AM–2PM 7AM–2PM 8AM–2PM

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 28

Joy Maxfield

We were very pleased to find this little restaurant off the beaten path. The food was very good and its evident someone in the kitchen knows what theyre doing. Soups were excellent. Hence the 4 stars. Would have given it 5 stars except for two things; Our young waitress was pretty lousy; she was slow to get us everything; drinks, menus, etc. , and she didnt seem to care that we were waiting way too long. Also, during our waiting, we noticed how really filthy and dusty the display shelves in the eating area were. Yuk. We hope the kitchen isnt like the eating area. When did you last clean??? Suggestion - hire more help on the weekends.

Jonathan Keen

Not bad flavors for breakfast food, but the coffee was weak and the portions were small. What really prevented me from coming back here was the cat that was hanging out inside while we were eating. This obviously wasnt a one time thing because our seats were covered in cat hair as well as our clothes.

Jorge Matias Caviglia

Great coffee and breakfast. Friendly staff, friendly customers, even friendlier cat that comes to sit w/ you and purrs. Nice background music. WiFi. Outlets. Customers are friendly, talk softly. And there are all those awesome smells coming f/ the kitchen.

Lydia McDonald

The best coffee!! I love their Chautauqua blend, cant get coffee that great from anywhere else! The quality is top notch! Stop in their adorable cafe for a yummy sandwich or gourmet meal! Really nice people with a gem of a place! Make sure to stop!!

Frank Stallone

This place has a ton of character and charm. The coffee was great (we were happy they had almond milk) and the food was fantastic. We ordered the eggs benedict and omelette with spinach and mushrooms. The eggs were perfectly cooked. Fabulous toast!

Wanda Gingerich

Quaint place. Nothing around. Locals drive for miles around and park along the road for brunch. Local young waitstaff. Indoor and outdoor seating with personality. A must visit. Eggs Benedict is a must.

Ron Antonucci

Good coffee. But came in when they were super-busy and the one waitress was not happy to see us. Pancakes were way over-priced, skimpy, not thoroughly cooked and rather bland. Good coffee, though.

Shirley Buecksler

Stedman Cafe was an amazing find! Great food, great staff, and we enjoyed talking with the owner, also. We will be back the next time we travel out east! The perfect spot for breakfast.

Tammy Schack

Old country time store. LOVE the building and the new addition downstairs. Fabulous Mom and Pop with delicious food and coffee!!! Bring a laptop and relax! Ahhh.

John Cummings

Coming in from hunting in the cold and wet, there was nothing better than sitting by the wood stove and a a great lunch or late breakfast! So glad youre here!

Deborah Schier

What a great place for breakfast! Food was wonderful and excellent service! Very unique place! Cant wait for the wine cellar to open! We will be back!

Brendan Halbohm

Stedman Cafe is hosts an incredible atmosphere for breakfast & lunch! Perfect spot for a date, meeting, or a quick coffee stop!

Amber Mann

Amazing food, coffee and atmosphere! We even had a kitty that shared our seat. Felt like we were right at home!

Ron Bystrom

What a cool place at a little intersection out in the country. Great home cooking and super nice people.

Sean Keller

A very charming diner with very tasty food. We stopped there a few times last time we were in that area.

Jeremy Lenz

Great food, reasonable pricing! Just wish they stayed open later.

Denise Minge

great service, excellent food and coffee.