The Comfy Cow New Albany
| Category: | Ice Cream Shop |
| Address: | 109 E Market St, New Albany, IN 47150, USA |
| Phone: | +1 812-924-7197 |
| Site: | thecomfycow.com |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 12–9PM 12–9PM 12–9PM 12–9PM 12–10PM 12–10PM 12–9PM |
Location
Photos 52
Reviews 47
SU
Susan B.
The ice cream is fantastic, the servers were good, but the portion for the Flight of Flavors was a bit disappointing. I paid the same amount for a waffle cone and got probably 3x the ice cream as my sister who ordered the flight, it gave two sampler-spoon fulls of each flavor. Had expected a bit more for the price.
ST
starr peterson
What a cheeky place! The atmosphere (and the bathrooms) are very nice, clean, and appealing. The menu is a bit intimidating when theres a huge line behind you, but the ice cream is yummy! My hubs had the root beer float and was in heaven! Would love to come back anytime!
BR
Bruce Andis
Wide variety of tasty, homemade-style ice cream. The chocolate-mocha was pretty darn good. The interior decor at this location is reminiscent of an old-fashioned soda shop. And the young women behind the counter were preternaturally happy.
PA
Paul Jolly
Lots of delicious ice cream flavors and all the free samples youd like. Funky cool decor and the staff has always been very nice. Selection seems smaller than at other locations, but still pretty vast.
KI
Kim Briner
There were so many choices and the staff helped us by giving quite a few samples to try and when we couldnt decide they suggested a split cup with two flavors in one scoop. It was great!
TY
Tyson Rexroat
Extremely overpriced for mediocre ice cream. 2 stars only because of the staff. $10.65 for a small shake and a ice cream cookie. And the cookie was so hard, I didnt finish it.
HO
Holly Twospoons
Delicious Ice Cream. Comfy Cow knows what they are doing. They have some creative flavors and they have a seasonal menu which makes going there a new experience each time.
JE
Jeff Jarecki
If youre into good small batch ice cream, youve come to the right place. If youre into bourbon, even better! Get a scoop of the bourbon ball and thank me later!
AA
Aaron Imlay
Always a huge selection of great ice cream and yummy treats. It was a bit understaffed when I was there, but it stills gets a five star.
DE
Debbie V.
Beautiful refurbished vintage storefront. Ice cream is handmade. Customer service is always attentive. Brown butter peanut brittle.
TE
Ted Bear
Very tasty milkshakes! Tried this place recently and its great and the service is friendly. If you like sweets this is your place
C
C Beringer
Greatest ice cream in the area! I always try one of the monthly special flavor after my Salon visit next door at Nicoles.
CH
Chad Garvey
Awesome high quality ice cream with locally driven, creative flavors. You definitely get what you pay for here.
CA
Carole Davidson
The ice cream is very good and the staff did a great job waiting on customers on a very busy night!
NI
Nichole Bridgewater
The bourbon ball and the coffee ice cream are so great. And the staff is usually very friendly
KA
Karen Grimes
Excelice cream. Is pricy but good for the occasional treat. Staff is friendly and helpful.
JA
Jay Smith
Best ice cream I can ever remember eating. Very pleasant staff. Eclectic decorations.
AN
Angelica Wiseman
Really cute decor and atmosphere, with reaaallly good ice cream. Yum!
CA
Caleb Creel
Best ice cream and milkshakes anywhere. Really cool location.
KA
Katherine King
The best traditional ice cream options with a local twist.
JE
Jeremy Zipp
Seriously good ice cream! Waffle cones are so delicious!
DA
David
Excellent pastries, awesome service, great atmosphere
ME
Melissa L
Excellent ice cream, nice atmosphere, great service!
KE
Kerry Barbato
Their always out of flavors even earlier in the day
CH
Chrishonda Jones
Clean, great customer service & delicious ice cream!
JO
John Fisher
Really cool atmosphere and there ice cream is good
MA
Mark Ratzloff
The very best icecream! We love your decor!!!
JO
Joshua Barraza
So good! And great people working there.
AD
Adam McNary
Great flavors offered and friendly people
PE
Peter Sieg
Fun atmosphere and delicious ice cream!
GE
George Johnson
Ice cream was delicious and was quiet.
TY
Tyler Neal
Great ice cream. The brownie was stale.
GA
Gabriel Hublar
icecream...really really good icecream
CH
Chris Knaffle
Very nice place. Delicious ice cream.
KE
Keith Brown
Good Ice Cream and friendly service.
TW
tw danner
Good ice cream neat atmosphere
AM
Amanda No
I love their rotating specials
CA
Carol Flynn
Wonderful! Lots of flavors.
MA
Marti Day
Super delicious ice cream!
VI
vikas sharma
great place good selection
KI
Kiersten Fenwick
Best ice cream in town.
HE
Heidi Paller
Yummy! Friendly service
IZ
Izza Marie
Expensive, but Great!!!
JA
Jason Crago
Great ice cream!
RO
Ross Reyes
Good ice cream
CH
Chris C
Awesome sauce
TO
Tonya Shaffer
35 most recent searches
Other organizations
Photos
Photos of comments
