Your Treasure Shop

Category:	Consignment Shop
Address:	52 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA
Phone:	+1 845-343-8443
Site:	facebook.com
Rating:	3.6
Working:	10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–5PM 12–3PM

Location

Photos 5

Reviews 8

A Private User

I was in Middletown for one night, and went online to find shopping for Sunday morning on our way out of town. I called the store and got their hours, so I knew theyd be there and open. We drove specifically to them, arriving 15 minutes before opening. The male owner rudely told me I had to sit and wait till noon, that he had to get things out of the store before I could go in (I asked the female owner what they do if it rains, how do they get people into the store. She really didnt get it, so I think he was just a jerk). I explained that we were from out of town, came there specifically after finding them on the internet, and he didnt care. My husband wanted to leave, but stupid me I stayed. I ended up only getting tennis balls. Everything was overpriced - example, a dish sold in the dollar stores was marked $3. Ive never gotten so little at such a big second hand shop. Waste of our time.

Incredible DJS

I walked in and asked if they had a book section. The man behind the counter pointed to there book section. As I walked over there I noticed that he was staring at me the whole time I was in the store. I felt very uncomfortable and decided to leave. Maybe they dont want african americans shopping at their store. I wont ever step foot back in this place. I was hoping to buy some history books and spend money.

gregory koch

I lke this store, not love it. Yes, they had a lot of great stuff. Yes, they were friendly. Yes, there are a million great treasures here. BUT it was over priced for a consignment store. Forget it if you were looking for a thrift store. I went in here looking for agreat deal not another place to buy new and used consumer goods at near retail price

Carol Sullivan-Besdansky

Disappointing. I was hoping to find some decent deals and have a fun shopping experience at a thrift shop. This is a thrift shop priced more like a gift shop. The owners also have an unfriendly "no haggle" type of attitude and seem unapproachable. I have actually gone twice and had the same experience both times. Too bad.

A Private User

Beautiful glass, antiques, pictures..you name it..they have it! Not only the best I have been in around Middletown..but the best in all of Orange County. Displayed so nicely and the prices fantastic. Worth a visit for sure.....no disappointment. Robert and Colleen Benedict

A Private User

I always feel welcome when I come into Your Treasure Shop. Tons of great Stuff, I found the prices to be very fair. They even have a half off area, and $1 area. Could check stuff out for hours. I give it an A++

guymard

Family owned, local for over 20 years, alittle but if everything!

Jack Crinnion

Nice people interesting items