Cookie Dough Creamery

Category:	Ice Cream Shop
Address:	7227 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085, USA
Phone:	+1 614-547-0660
Site:	cookie-dough-creamery.com
Rating:	4.3
Working:	11AM–9:45PM 11AM–9:45PM 11AM–9:45PM 11AM–9:45PM 11AM–10:45PM 11AM–10:45PM 1–9:45PM

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 27

Spyke Fleming

I was a little underwhelmed. With all the hype from Channel 6, I was really looking forward to checking it out. First it is very expensive. - Tiny little cups. high prices, Especially when you are talking a soft serve. Second there was no sample options. If you choose poorly on your ice cream your out of luck. In the end it is very similar all of the yogurt shops around town except you are not paying by weight, and they have several cookie doughs to choose from. The cookie dough was good! For the cookie dough lovers out there this is your spot to get a cup full of dough!

Brookelyn Johnson

Really great price for everything they offer. You buy a cup not a weight and you can fill it with whatever you want. If you want all cookie dough or all ice-cream they will actually give you a discounted price for the cup because you arent taking toppings. The cookie dough taste and texture is perfect and everything is made daily on site. It was very clean(wasnt terribly busy when my family and I went but even after they got through the group that came in after, they went to cleaning). Definitely a place to stop and try.

Shane James

I dont even like cookie dough. When folks rave about their secret, guilty pleasure of raw cookie dough I scoff and turn my nose up at it. But Cookie a Dough Creamery is the TRUTH. The ice cream is so creamy and smooth and delicious and HOW DID YOU GUYS DO THIS ITS NUTS. And then they have peanut butter cookie dough that makes me salivate in the wee hours of the morn. Its all made without raw ingredients and still tastes remarkably like the real thing (or some Im told by several helpless folks addicted to raw dough).

Muhammad Khair

I really appreciate this style of place the fact that they let you fill up the cup after you pay for it instead of charging after weighing the cup allows you to get as much as you want without paying to much as well as the arcade tables made it for a great time allowing me to enjoy a unhealthy amount of cookie dough and video games at the same time I know my reviews all over the place but in short I would recommend this place to any person with a pulse

Malanie Beverly

I love cookie dough with a passion, as well as ice cream. So this place, where you serve yourself a base of cookie dough (I chose sugar cookie dough), pour on soft serve (Butter Pecan!), and then sprinkle the topping magic...is a happy place. The price is fair, the product is spectacular, and the service is great. I compare this creamery to Menchies Frozen Yogurt--but the Cookie Dough Creamery is my favorite.

Heather Haines

The cookie dough aspect was fun and tasty, but the ice cream was nothing to write home about. Plus, the ice cream wasnt very cold. You pay by cup size instead of weight, which I wasnt the biggest fan of. I like to be able to mix my ice cream and eat everything together, but with the limited cup size you have to fill it to feel like you are getting any value.

Elizabeth Watson

This place is amazing. Im personally in love with cookie dough and would often go to other places to get cookie dough ice cream anyway. So if youre like me, this is place is going to be heaven. The ice cream is soft served (my favorite) and theres a variety toppings that seem to change every so often. I would recommend The Cookie Dough Creamery to everyone!

Jessica Wise

Wow! My daughters and I really enjoyed our first trip here. The flavor combos are amazing and the cookie dough was delicious. I highly recommend the cookies and cream. The prices were great too! I actually expected it to be much more expensive than it was. My girls loved the topping free for all, and loved doing there own imaginative thing!

C Fetz

To the owners: You should give mad props to your employees. When we came in for the first time 5/15, the employees were super friendly and helpful. Not only that, but they kept up with all the random little messes and made sure your business was impeccably clean. Plus, delicious ice cream! Love it!!!

Kurt Lewis

This place is great! You will pay a little more than youd expect for each cup size, but you pay by size, not weight. In the end, you wont need much, as the cookie dough is rich and quickly filling. A great selection of toppings and yogurt flavors as well!

Andrew Arheit

Unique idea. Its a make-your-own sundae bar - pay a set price for a small, medium or large and then make it yourself - load it up with 4 types of homemade cookie dough, 8 or so flavors of soft serve ice cream and a bunch of different toppings.

kawa kuranosuke

Exactly what it says on the tin. Eggless cookie dough in four flavors (Sugar Vanilla, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter, Oreo) with soft serve ice cream and various toppings. Grab a cookie dough sandwich the size of your fist or take home a tub.

Brian Rao

Wow! Great place to get cookie dough AND ice cream for a low price. Friendly and casual atmosphere with great workers! Very unique compared to a traditional ice cream shop and I would definitely recommend a visit to Cookie Dough Creamery!

Jason Wheeler

Its a fun twist on the self serve ice cream shop. The cookie dough is delicious. Its made without egg so its alright to eat raw. The best part is the cocktail arcade cabinets, which are free in the winter months.

Shawnna Schlaegel

We love this place, we took our schoolage daycare program and there was something for every child to enjoy. The staff were very nice and were very patient with 26 children all at one time.

James Suttinger

Everything was great expect for the teenage girl laying on the floor behind the counter, feet propped up on some crates while staring at her phone. Didnt even seem bothered we walked in.

Tony Galante

Unique concept and very good cookie dough! I thought the price was cheap ~$4 for a small and a lot of cookie dough and unlimited toppings/ice cream you could fit in the bowl.

Wyatt Moore

I recently discovered this place this recent summer and this has been the spot to satisfy my sweet tooth ever since. if youve never been here, youre in for quite a surprise!

Laura Maurer

This place is my dream come true. Cookie dough on the bottom and ice cream on the top! Delicious and absolutely worth it to go back again and again! Safe and great flavor!

DeWayne Ackerman jr

Great local shop, sooooo good for the price, and they have classic arcade games. The cookie dough is safe with no eggs. Make sure you try the sugar cookie dough sometime

The Nerdos!

Very good my kids love it, the light is kind of bad in the back and you could drive past it without noticing it but all in all great place.

Jeanine Momenee

Cookie dough is one of my favorite ice cream toppings and Cookie Dough Creamery takes cookie dough ice cream up a notch. Delicious!!

Sarah McDermott

It was very hard to find. Expensive with little ice cream flavors to choose from. Not sure we would return.

J.D. Archer

Cool concept, but all the cookie dough is left at the bottom after eating the ice cream. Need wider bowls?

Mike Brown

Very special place. Eating cookie dough in public never felt so good. Haha. The ice cream is good too.

Rebecca Glock

The cookie dough and ice cream are delicious. The pricing is super reasonable. Absolutely worth a trip