The Original Goodie Shop

Category:	Bakery
Address:	2116 Tremont Center, Upper Arlington, OH 43221, USA
Phone:	+1 614-488-8777
Site:	theoriginalgoodieshop.com
Rating:	4.6
Working:	7AM–6PM 7AM–6PM 7AM–6PM 7AM–6PM 7AM–7PM 7AM–5PM Closed

Location

Photos 87

Reviews 16

Mooserella 76

Coming here since I was little. The bakery and icing smell takes me way back. We always have our birthday cakes made here. Their longjohns, or thats what they were called, are still the best and sell out fast. I want to order a dozen just for myself. Mainly the chocolate and maple iced versions, yum!! Cookies are good and they often carry some very old style cookies on special occasions. Ex. Springerlees, cutouts, etc. Even selling King cakes soon. They sell single cake pieces as well. Not sure if its unsold cakes or what but theyll definitely satisfy a sweet tooth. I was so saddened when this place posted an out of business notice a couple of years ago, but breathed a sigh of relief when a previous owner bought back many items and reopened. I remember the community rallied some funds to help them buy back some of the sold equipment. Either way Im so so glad its still there.

Sheena Richardson

I am so disappointed with the gender reveal cake I ordered. I purposefully choose a simple design and they still messed it up. The cake was supposed to be pink and blue and instead it was red and blue. I posted a pic of what I wanted and what I got. When I called about it they said they noticed the color dried wrong and STILL LEFT IT LIKE THAT! They said giving me $5-10 off was the best they could do. Extremely unprofessional and they lack pride in their craft. I was even expected to get my own ice cream cone as part of the design. Never again!

Mandy Kessler

I used The Original Goodie Shop for a selection of desserts for my wedding. I got a few of practically every item they carried. Putting in the order was so casual and friendly, and they had it ready when I needed. Great service. I was too distracted on the day of the wedding to try any of them, but when I got back from the honeymoon a week later, there were some left over, and they were *still* delicious. I definitely recommend this place for anything from a casual doughnut to a larger wedding order like mine.

A Private User

Ive been visiting this shop since 1967 and Ive never been disappointed in the goodies Ive bought. Try their cinnamon sticks - Ive never tasted anything so good! Their creme horns are amazing too. I buy their chicken pot pies to keep in my freezer for a fast, delicious meal. They sell out of some things, especially on Saturdays, so I call ahead to have them save my favorites!

Rachael Binder

I grew up on the best cookies and pastries in Columbus from the Tremont Goodie Shop, and now my children love it too! We no longer live in Arlington, but are more than willing to make the trip! The smiley face cookies are still my favorite!

John MacAdam

Our office has a weekly donut club. We sample donuts from around the city. A co-worker brought donuts in from here. By far the best we have had!

Julia Winters

My kids love this place and so do I. Everything is wonderful and worth the splurge (of money and calories!). YUM!

Ben Underwood

Ive been coming here since a small child and always love it. The staff are good and the cookies are delicious!

Daniel Coleman

Excellent donuts and cinnamon sticks. I have only been here a couple times but will be back.

Daniel B

Their cinnamon sticks are small but mighty. Since I was a kid, my favorite doughnut place.

Tom Smith

Making custom cookies for a party... they just need to stick more peanut butter blossoms!