Sugar Shack

Category:	Coffee Shop
Address:	4058 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30319, USA
Phone:	+1 404-816-6161
Site:	sugarshackatlanta.com
Rating:	4.4
Working:	8AM–9PM 8AM–9PM 8AM–9PM 8AM–9PM 8AM–11PM 8AM–11PM 8AM–9PM

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 34

Glenda Burrus

I ordered a whole Red Velvet Cheesecake. Oh my goodness. I cant describe how good this thing tasted. The first time I had it was actually and one of their sister restaurants Einsteins in Midtown. This cheesecake is so luscious and almost organic. The chocolate mixed with the red velvet cake are a winner in my book. The cake comes in a nice hard box. Not flimsy. It also comes indented with marks so you know where to slice it evenly. Wet the knife between slicing to keep the cut clean. This dessert is heaven and will shine in anyones dinner table or office party. I purchased it for my team at Thanksgiving and everyone raved about it. I will probably purchase another one for Christmas.

Nalandra Barton

I have been a few times before (a little more than a few) and have had a great experience. Today I went and there was a lady with short blond hair that served me this time. I ordered the veggie panini and took a seat to wait. After atleast 20 min I still hadnt been served, so I went to the counter to ask for a refund so I could leave. The server told me that maybe I should call ahead next time. Awesome, except the gentlemen that came in about 3 min behind me was served before me and was more than half through his sandwhich before I got up to ask for a refund to leave. Great advice for the next person though.

Heather Manning

Fantastic. Stumbled in one night after a few drinks in Atlanta wanting some dessert. The restaurant I was at had a mediocre dessert menu. Sugar Shack popped up after googling "dessert spots in Atlanta". Service was quick and friendly, with a great selection of cookies, cupcakes, full size cake and other sweets. Havent tried their regular menu food. I liked this place and their service so much that I special ordered a cake for a coworker(for her last day) and drove 45 min to pick it up. Will continue to visit this place when Im in the area.

Melissa Woolridge

I am a baker, and these baked goods are what baked goods are supposed to taste like. Anyone who says the cupcakes are mediocre doesnt know what a cupcake is supposed to taste like. They have flavor, are moist, the icing isnt hard. The sugar cookies and the shortbread cookies were the best I have ever tasted. Ever. They were super buttery and soft. The lemon square was insanely moist and delicious. The scones were crumbly yet moist. Love this place!!!!

Rachel B

Very relaxing atmosphere for such a tiny place. I thought I was going to get claustrophobic at first, but I was pleasantly surprised by the fact that I felt comfortable. I ordered a toffee nut coffee, delicious! Ordered a balsamic chicken panini, and let me just say, it was better than Newks sandwiches! They have the best eclairs too! And chocolate dipped biscotti!!

Meg M

I came in off a flight from Baltimore, hot, tired, and thirsty! The staff was very friendly...encouraged me to take my time :) The sandwich and coffee I got really hit the spot. I could relax, chill out, charge my phone, and read my book. The desserts that I noticed people purchasing looked and smelled incredible

Shamara White

First visit, not throughly impressed. Although my egg dill cheese bagel was decent it was lack luster. The eggs appeared processed not fresh, didnt see any egg white, it had large tomato slices vs diced or thinner cut and it lacked salt. Bagel was soft. Maybe lunch is more flavorful. Ill try again in the future.

Lewis Merit

Average cupcakes and baked goods with friendly staff. On par with Panera Bread or perhaps Kroger. Not as good as Publix bakery, well short of Gigis. Worth a trip if youre close by, not worth the drive if youre far away. Note: items are not baked on site.

C Rodriguez

Yes yes yes yes yes!!!! You must go here! Super duper cute, staff couldnt be nicer, coffee (Brookhaven special lend) couldnt be better, and the desserts are heaven on earth :) this is a special treat for anyone who visits!

Christina Forsman

My hubby and I came here for dessert. It was yummy. There were so many options. He had coffee and I had hot tea with our slices of pure divinity. Everything was reasonably priced. The servings of cake are huge!

Tad Scobey

Great Friendy neighborhood breakfast spot for breakfast sandwiches and muffins! Great coffee, too! Friendy staff and fast service. My favorite is the Egg BLT on Cibatta. Trust me it is delicious!

Addison Williams

Friendly staff, cool vibe, tasty food and drinks. Service was a little slow and theres not a lot of space, but its worth a try to see whether its a good or bad fit for you (its not for everyone).

Anna Mamontova

First time visiting and the food was delicious, amazing customer service, and very calm and relaxing vibe. Indoor and outdoor seating, menu variety and overall great experience! Highly recommend

Dianna M

Delicious sandwiches and teas. The staff was super friendly and helpful. Also the desserts are delicious decadence! Stop in for a quick bite for your sweet tooth and you wont be disappointed.

Diane Fields

Went on August 25th to buy cupcakes but ended up getting a slice of Red Velvet cake, cookies. The cake was so dry and some ends were hard. Very disappointed dont think Ill go back.

Michael F. D. Anaya

The stuff they make there is okay (cookies and muffins)...but the stuff their "private bakery" makes is very good. The chocolate brownies and apple pie were awesome!

Adriana Vega

Pretty pissed off when I ordered an apple pie to go and get home to find they gave me a blueberry pie.. apple pie.. blueberry pie... mmm they sound nothing alike.

Kyle Conarro

Good place to grab to go baked goods, meet a friend, or work. Good prices, good coffee, good food. Easy parking during the day. Also beer options which is nice.

Dana Bourke

This is one of my favorite Brookhaven spots to grab a quick breakfast with a friend! Delicious ciabatta breakfast sandwiches and $1 coffee between 8-10.

Dale Brantley

Im not big on sweets, but I have eaten a lot of their breakfast and lunch menu and everything Ive had has been amazing every time.

Cherisse Miller

I ordered banana nut muffins. So sweet but good. Ive also ordered a breakfast sandwich that wasnt that good. Parking is horrible.

Chris Collado

Come for the dessert and pastry selection. Within walking distance to much of Brookhaven, I come down for early lunches as well.

Travel With Ralph

That turkey & gouda is the beat sandwich on earth wow. I drive 30 minutes across just to get that sandwhich. Incredible!!!

Konstantin B

Absolutely delicious food, coffee, and deserts. A favorite of ours to stop in to for breakfast on an early morning walk.

Brenda Ortiz

Good latte, nice place, many pastries and bakery. Service is very good and friendly, free Wifi, big parking lot.