Neidhammer Coffee Co.

Reviews 45

JA

James Wood

I wish I could upgrade my five star review to six stars, because Neidhammer keeps inching closer and closer towards a second home for me. The hospitality, ingenuity, and flexilibity of the staff here are the best Ive seen in the city, and Neidhammer is rapidly shaping itself into a cornerstone of the Near Eastside. Working here one afternoon, I asked for a very specific drink, one that the staff had never made before. They experimented with joy trying to make it, and the result was delicious. Later that day, I was spotted finishing a coffee, and the manager brought me a warm apple crumble muffin on the house. Small gestures like these carry with them the welcoming warmth I seek from a neighborhood coffee shop -- not just a place to get caffeinated, but a place to be with others who give a damn about each other. I genuinely look forward to days where I can spend a morning or afternoon at Neidhammer, supporting this amazing business.

---

SA

SamJoy Jordan

The owners were there and were extremely friendly! I told them I had missed the Yelp event the day prior, and they kindly gave me a tour around the place. I love the vibe of the place; the place is hip and well decorated. Its very cozy, and, the best part for me as a college student, theres an outlet at every table! Haha! No more searching for outlets or the awkward "excuse me?" As for food, they get their baked goods from a local place -- I cant remember where. All I can say is they looked scrumptious, but I sadly didnt grab a bite. I did get coffee -- just something simple: an iced Americano. It was smooth to the finish! I would love to go there again whenever I have more time in my mornings.

---

GA

Gavin Gregory

Waited over 15 minutes for a latte and carmel macchiato. When we finally got them they were lukewarm and the carmel was in the latte, not the macchiato A lady behind us had to go up and ask them if they could heat hers up after she got it as well. The staff was super friendly, and dont get me wrong I think they were trying, but no one really seemed to know what they were doing. The older gentleman taking orders didnt know how to work the machinery or assist the clearly overwhelmed girl making most of the drinks. I will give Neidhammer another shot but it will be a while.

---

CH

Christianna McCormick

My Husband and I love this family run, locally own coffee shop. Its beautiful interior and gourmet drinks make the experience magical. Check them out for events, a good time with great company, or a relaxing place to get work done. We love it so much that we got married upstairs in the Neidhammer building!

---

SS

Ssheldon618

Ive only been once. But the atmosphere was awesome. The old building, the antique feel and the open space are really a breath of fresh air. Not to mention their pour over coffee as probably the best tasting pour over Ive had in quite some time. Its a must if youre in Indy and on the near east side.

---

ST

Stephen Sanner

This is my favorite haunt! The staff is exceedingly friendly, and the prices are very reasonable. Every table has a power outlet under it, which makes working while sipping a delicious coffee a breeze. I love everything, but I recommend the americano with steamed almond milk, or any of the smoothies.

---

AS

Ashesh Goswami

Very friendly staff, rustic decor, and a great place to read or do your work. They have pour over coffee, as well as the regular latte and Cappuccino. Every table has its own charging port which is great. Overall, a nice atmosphere with good coffee.

---

NA

Nathan Jeter

Between the Neidhammers extremely delicious coffee, wonderfully friendly staff, and awesome space, I cant decide which Im a bigger fan of. Plus, with Ash and Elm Cidery in the same room, I cant recommend a visit enough!

---

MI

Michelle Wallace

Great place to meet friends, study, work, or purely enjoy a good coffee! The baristas are very personable and knowledgeable about the origins of their coffee. Great place to check out on the near east side!

---

BR

Bradley Goode

I go here every morning. This is the best coffee place Ive ever been too. The coffee is slays good and the staff are always friendly and smiling. I highly recommend at least trying this place out.

---

BR

Brian Dew

Theyve done a great job with this old building. This isnt Starbucks so dont expect fast, assembly line product. The coffee was fantastic as were the pastries. Will definitely be back

---

TA

Taylor Bales

Loved it!! Super cute, perfect for a date, your morning stop, anytime! The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable. Cant wait to go again.

---

KA

Kara Hanley

Owners are amazing and know good coffee! I always feel so welcome when I visit and love that they have outlets at every table!

---

EM

Emily Lemke

New coffee shop offering coworking and event space. Staff is great to work with and the atmosphere is to die for - LOVE IT.

---

JO

Joel Kempson

What a local coffee house should be. Inviting, chic, with great coffee and pastries. Visit it and find out for yourself.

---

ST

Steve Caldwell

Love this hidden gem. Coffee and people are top notch. Had a work event up in the theatre which was a ton of fun.

---

DA

David Michael Paxton

Wonderfully friendly staff, great coffee, and a comfortably rustic atmosphere! We love coming here!

---

AA

Aaron Woods

Cold brew is full and exciting. Parking is across the street. Friendly folks and usually quiet.

---

JO

John Buterbaugh

Great coffee, superb atmosphere, and great friendly service. Get here and enjoy a good read

---

ME

Megin Worsham

Great coffee in a cute location. They also have a hard cider bar, and a work space upstairs

---

HE

Heather Meadows

Family run, friendly, personal service. Good coffee, wonderful muffins

---

LO

lofi glam

Amazing coffee and amazing customer service in a charming setting.

---

JO

Jordan Bishop

Great people work there! Awesome place to catch up with friends!

---

GR

Greg Coley

Love the space, the location, and the selection of beverages.

---

TI

Tim Gomolak

Updated and modern interior. Friendly staff and patrons.

---

K

K Ward

Atmosphere feels fake and the hipster vibe was terrible

---

MI

Miguel Cervantes

Awesome. Fancy. Friendly. Inviting. Did I say awesome?

---

KE

Kelsey Walker

I love their tea selection and its a great work place.

---

KA

Karl Boyd

Awesome experience!! Owners are a very nice couple!!

---

ZA

Zach Adamson

Great coffee, friendly neighborhood meeting place.

---

JO

Joy Elliott

Great atmosphere. Lovely people. Amazing coffee!

---

BE

Benjamin Pidgeon

Friendl, free wifi, awesome brick work inside.

---

OT

Otis Bibbs

Nice decor, excellent setting, friendly staff

---

ST

Stephan Kline

Service was slow. But coffee was very good.

---

NI

Nick

Excellent coffee in fantastic environment.

---

AM

Amy Walsman

Delicious coffee and cheery atmosphere!

---

DA

Daniel Jeffries

Amazing coffee. Excellent atmosphere.

---

D

D Skipper

Watching you on fox 59 was painful

---

DA

David G. Vanderstel

Great coffee in a great building.

---

JE

Jerod Harris

Great coffee. Classy environment.

---

DA

Dan Moss

Worked well for a baby shower.

---

DA

Daniel Engle

A Seattle worthy coffee shop.

---

MA

Margaret Clark

Staff friendly coffee good

---

CA

Cameron Stemshorn

Incredible cold brew

---

JA

Jared Campbell

Authentic German

---

---