Island Thrift

Reviews 48

FR

Frank Clementi

This is supposed to be a thrift store. Not a variety antique department store with outrageous prices. I swear the staff looks up the value of items being sold online and tags them at mint condition prices. There is rarely anything in mint or near mint condition in the mold fumed place. For example, go price out any collectible items in stock and behold, prices well above what you see online. Then take a peek at the condition and notice 98% of the time its priced as Mint while in mediocre to poor condition!!! Keep in mind all their inventory is donation based which means "FREE". The only way to pass break even is on Sunday or holiday when sale items (tagged in some sort of color system) are 50% off.

---

MA

Martha Masone

went into the store this afternoon. signs all over shoe dept. all boots 50% off today only. at cashier with pair of boots and she told me the sale was yesterday. cashier went over to a short grey haired woman who i assume was the manager to ask her if the sale was still on. the woman came over said no it was yesterday and refused to honor the signs. instead she walked over to the shoe dept and took the signs down. Without even an apology for the stores error. Hence I did not purchase the boots. you would think the 12 dollars I would have saved was coming out of her pocket. customer service is essential even at the thrift store. because I work hard for every dollar I earn.

---

MI

Michael Brodsky

Island Thrift - selection clothing as well as some merchandise on the Shelf if youre looking for an old record is a possibility of finding a gym a month junk the stuff that most people are looking for for a convenient price you may find something there that you dont expect to see worth checking out to see what you might find what you might find for a limited amount of cash that you need to spend

---

JA

Janis T.

Some good finds but overall too expensive, especially since they get all the items for free! They use the Veterans name to pick up donations from houses at curbside. I am curious how much money the US Veterans actually receive. I think the owners get the lions share of profits (which are tremendous).

---

JE

jeannine t

Its hit or miss at this place ,weekends are good cause theres 4 sometimes 5 colors half off. thats when u really get good deals! Its like a big garage sale thats how i look at it. just go, im sure youll find something.

---

EL

Elide Garcia

Gran surtido de calzado y ropa de segunda mano a precio moderado. Para todas las edades

---

CH

Charles Peter Watson

Definitely, a great place to purchase second-hand products at low prices, whether theyre on sale or not. You will find the occasional quality items at reduced prices, depending on where you find them.

---

ED

edgar gonzalez

I love this thrift store, they have so many options to choose from. They constantly have deals on everything, they even have a wide DVD collection and book collection to choose from.

---

TO

Todd Merritt

Huge store, good turnover of inventory means new stuff every dy. Prices for a thrift store ru on the high side, but deals still can be found.

---

AN

Andrew Negron

They have a wide variety of stuff from cloths to electronics. Staff is friendly but the prices are a little high buy thrift standards.

---

MA

Marc .P.NY

I like to go here from time to time to see what old electronics I can get my hands on. Their stock is always change so its hit or miss

---

LU

Luz González

Hay cosas muy buenas y te atienden muy bien!!!

---

JA

Jaclyn Smith

The cleanest, best organized thrift store I have ever been to! Been coming to this company since they were Selden Thrift

---

VI

Vicki Martinez

Great stuff, most of the prices are very good. Each week there are 2 colored tags 1/2 off, on Sunday 4 colors 1/2 off

---

RO

Rosie Soriano

my favorite thrift shop!! friendly staff and always a great find ! definitely recommend everyone to check it out

---

AS

Ashley Greklek

Alright. Not as good as Centereach store, but its still fun to poke through. Great Electronics section though!

---

KE

Kevin Orlando

Prices are hit or miss. Sometimes they overcharge, sometimes they undercharge. But they have good sales.

---

DA

Danielle OKeeffe

Love this place! Great prices, great sales! You can almost certainly find some hidden treasures here.

---

OS

Oscar Gonzalez

Buena atención y buenos productos !

---

JE

jeff fuhrmann

Love this place always have something for myself and the family. If on a budget its the place to go

---

RO

Robert Vecchio

Huge place with a huge selection of just about everything. Store and products are clean

---

MI

Michael Perkowski

Not a bad yhrift store but usuallu prices are a little high for second hand stuff

---

LI

Lisa Pontecorvo

I like this one better then the Centereach one. Better finds.

---

AN

Angela B

Love to bring my donations there and help our veterans...

---

LU

Lupe Rivera

Every Wednesday in July have 4 colors 50% off

---

DA

DANISSA LA TORRE

I bought my dining set 50% off. Good deal!

---

JA

Jani Narducci

Way too expensive. Its second hand goods.

---

PA

Paulie Saviano

Very nice and clean place. Very organized

---

RO

Roberto Vilchez

You find the best things here sometimes.

---

KE

Kerry Bruno

Love the colored ticket sales every day!

---

MY

Myriam

Found some interesting stuff here

---

PE

Pete Mayo

Try putting the air condition on.

---

GE

George Aviles JR

They have lots of stuff there

---

JE

Jean Fig

There are really good deals!!

---

JA

Jack Roberts

Great merchant, great value.

---

DA

Daniel Voccia

The best thrift store ever

---

AN

Andrew stanley

Usually find something

---

JA

James Edenfield

Always a bargain here

---

AN

Antoinette Schoenthaler

Great place to shop

---

AL

Al Bque

Way overpriced !!!

---

LA

Latisa Webb

Loved the handbags

---

JO

Joseph Tomanelli

Quality Selections

---

RO

Rosalind Campanella

I love this place

---

CU

curtis sammarco

Not over priced.

---

JE

Jeff W

Good prices...

---

LE

Leisha Ware

LUVIN IT!!!

---

KE

Kevin Waxman

Great deals

---

DA

Damien Knoth

Very cool

---

---