P is for Pie Bake Shop

Category:	Bakery
Address:	2806 Corrine Dr, Orlando, FL 32803, USA
Phone:	+1 407-745-4743
Site:	crazyforpies.com
Rating:	4.9
Working:	7:30AM–4:30PM 7:30AM–4:30PM 7:30AM–4:30PM 7:30AM–4:30PM 7:30AM–4:30PM 7:30AM–4:30PM Closed

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 22

Geoffrey Prinz

We cannot be happier that we selected P is for Pie for our wedding! During the planning process we researched quite a few bakeries but were not all that excited about a large, over the top wedding cake and really had no idea which direction we wanted to go in. We found P is for Pie at a grand tasting event with Big City Catering and immediately feel in love with their products. Stacey was an absolute pleasure to work with throughout the entire planning process! She invited us to the shop for a more personalized tasking and was very accommodating and personable. For our wedding, we ended up having a small, two-tiered carrot cake for the traditional cake cutting as well as 3 flavors of cutie pies, Key Lime, Chocolate Peanut Butter and Vanilla Bean Cheesecake. All of them were to die for and were a hug hit with our Guests! We are still receiving rave comments from some family and friends, on both the cutie pies and the carrot cake. Regardless of if you are looking for a traditional wedding cake, or something more unique such as pies, I would strongly recommend looking into P is for Pie!! Stacey and team - thank you for your amazing service; It was such a pleasure working with you!

Madison Ickes

I am a very positive person and hate to give bad reviews. I came here on a Friday at 3 in the afternoon, and they did not have any pie left, all they had was carrot cake. I understand wanting your product to be fresh, but there has to be a better way to keep product in stock. Its not like I showed up right before closing, it was in the afternoon right before the weekend. I was dog sitting for my boss, and I passed this place every day on the way to her house. I was very excited for some pie, and I was not only disappointed but the girl behind the counter was not at all apologetic. I want to be clear: I was not at all rude to her about there being no pie. I know it was not her fault, but her indifferent attitude really made me sad.

Fred Brooks

One of the cute little storefronts that make the Audobon district what it is. I toured their bakery when they first opened and they make everything there. They even participate in compost Orlando. This place has a modern spin to the traditional pies and serve them in little mason jars. Small snacks that have lots of flavor. You cant go wrong with their coconut cream pie or the banana pudding pie! If you want whole pies, order in advance but it can get a little pricey. Definitely try the cookies that are basically bigger than your face. Not disappointing.

funtimemoney

Places like this stand out and for good reason. You never really know what to expect because theyre always changing up the recipes. Always a different savory or little pie. Their whoopee pies could put you in a coma theyre so good. The coffee they use is Stumptown. And they always switch it up. One day itll be French roast and another is a more fruitier flavor. Plus its family owned and family worked. Big plus from me on that. Owners are the kindest people youd ever meet.

Alison S

Wow amazing. Chocolate cream pie in a jar, caramel bread pudding, blueberry tart & cherry pie. Love the small sizes as they are all very rich so a small one is all you need. We ate two in store and took 2 different home. The cherry pie filling was excellent but because of its small size it was a bit overwhelmed with the crust. Cant wait to go back and try more! They were sold out of some items by 11 AM on a Saturday but they were baking more. Super friendly.

Cameron Carrion

Pie is now my new favorite dessert thanks to this homemade everything taste bud rollercoaster!! I had almost one of everything lol and it was hard to choose a favorite. What really stood out is key lime pie. Oh baby! Im not talking about some food colored green imitation pie. Im talking it tastes as if its caught fresh off a boat from the keys!! What else could you ask for! Phenomenal service? Done! Taste bud paradise? Done! Relaxing environment? Ohhhh its to legit to quit!

Eric Evans

What a wonderful treat for the senses! P is for Pie is really cute and welcoming upon first sight. Then the intoxicating smells of all the yummy treats envelope you like a blanket. We had to sample several of the available goodies, and everything was absolutely fantastic. The proprietors are warm and friendly, making you feel right at home. Well be back, even though we live hundreds of miles away. Highly Recommended!

Jorge Ant

Great place for superb pastries. The hand pies are delicious and the cheesecake bites are a must. My new years resolution was to eat better pastries and coffee, this place fits the bill. They have awesome Stumptown coffee. All their pastries and coffee are fairly priced. You must try this place. They also have a nice, clean and friendly atmosphere to eat there.

Susan Coppens

Our favorites are the vanilla bean cheesecake bites, apple pie, cinnamon buns, and coconut cake. Thank you Tara G. for bringing "P is for Pie" to Audubon Park! To the new owners, what a DELICIOUS job you are doing-we love having you here!!

Rodolfo Montilla

Came here for Pi Day earlier this year and fell in love. Theyre always coming up with unique flavors and keeping old traditional flavors around. Ive seen them at weddings from time to time as well. Love their pies. <3

Steve Wilbur

Had several item to sample, hand pies pecan and apple, very good loved the crust. Moon pie was amazing as was the mini smores pie. Just a fun pie place. And we know pie, own a pie bakery back home in phoenix.

Michael L.

I got the savory Mac n cheese hand pie. I hear the buffalo chicken and Mac n cheese hand pie is better so I definitely want to return to P is For Pie and order that and a dessert! Really cool spot in Orlando!

Corrine Graver

Cant get enough! Hard to pick but the oatmeal whoppie pie is my favorite! Especially on but one get one free whoopie Pie Wednesday hehe no but they really are delicious, everything Ive had from there is :)

Ryan Behar

This is a small bakery with huge flavor. The recipes are delicious and presented in a beautiful manner. There is always something new for me to try there.

Seth Shelnutt

Best bakery in Orlando! Ive yet to order anything I would not recommend! If they have Cinnamon Rolls make sure to get one! Their muffins are amazing too!

april bays

The owners are wonderful! I had the Spinach Artichoke Savory, and it was AMAZING! Cute little whoopie pies, just perfect! Highly recommend.

Munchkin G.F.

If you pass this place up... Youll be really sorry. Amazing desserts!! Amex not allowed but thats a stupid reason not to stop. Just sayin..

Eira Nieves

Fresh and flavorful ingredients. Definitely worth stopping by if you want something quick to hit the spot. Your tastebuds will thankyou.

Ashli Van Horn

Got a cinnamon roll and coffee; both were delicious! Staff were very friendly and helpful. Definitely a place I want to visit again!

Sheresa Absher

Great bakery items! Basic coffee. Wonderful, friendly staff. I had the triple berry wrapped pie and it was super great!!!

Jeff Nickel

Go on a Saturday and get whatever sheet pie they have made, it never disappoints. Great for custom pies made to order.