Oceans 5 Seafood Market & Eatery

Category:	Seafood Restaurant
Address:	99 NY-25A, Shoreham, NY 11786, USA
Phone:	+1 631-849-6414
Site:	oceans5seafood.com
Rating:	4.3
Working:	10AM–9PM 10AM–9PM 10AM–9PM 10AM–9PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 11AM–8PM

Location

Photos 51

Reviews 25

Steven Kuehne

I have been here many times. Always loved the food and the management is amazing. Recently, my cell phone was destroyed by a waiter spilling a beer on it. It was not done on purpose, it was definitely an accident. I did not get upset, because management promised that my phone would be replaced. One of the owners, Joe, has refused to pay for a new cell phone for me. He was nasty and condescending to me when I spoke with him on the phone. He was blaming me for leaving my phone on the table. REALLY? As much as I love the food and the staff that works here, I will never go back and spend my money, to put money in this mans pocket. Let me add that the spilled beer was also all over my and my wifes laps - - but we did not ask him to pay for the cleaning of or replacement of our clothes.

Roy Buccola

Bad Management-Great Food...I went in last Friday Night and the lady manager with the dark hair was riding a waiter for something. She followed him in the kitchen and proceeded to curse him out. Then a family of 4 came in and asked for a table..The same manager said that it was restaurant week and they needed a reservation. The husband pleaded with her that his wife was pregnant and they really wanted to eat there. The place was empty except for 1 table...and the manager would not budge. I got my food that I ordered and will not be going back-She needs to learn how to treat people with some compassion and respect. I will miss the food it is amazing...She also could use some advice on how to treat people by a server named Ian...He has always been a model on customer service

Juliette Doherty

I have had catered food from here and it was delicious for a summer party for 40 guests. I have eaten here and the food has been great. I went in today to buy fish and soup for takeout. The fluke was fresh and very good. The manhattan clam chowder was sour. I called to tell them the soup had turned. The person answering the phone identified himself as Joe, he was rude and was not well spoken. Joe never apologized once! Just said okay....Did not offer me a new soup or a refund. I suggested he remove the other soup that is in the case and he again answered okay. I will never get takeout soup from here again. This business does not teach its employees the importance of customer satisfaction.

Adam Gromacki

Greeted like we were in a high class restaurant by Kyle. The staff was very professional and courteous. The bread was very good. Lobster bisque superb, not at all salty. Salad was crisp and fresh. My wife had the Maryland crab cakra with rice and veggies. I had th garlicky mussells over linguini. Too die for. Not 1 grain of sand!!!. Not too crazy about the baker class. Too bready and no clam taste. Everything was served hot (temperature)wise. Next time we will try the cams casino. FIVE STARS. Adam & Carol, Middle Island.

Joy Heid

I buy fish at Ocean s five, because of convenience and liking fresh fish. I have tied to eat there but have been greeted with rudeness, long waits in an empty room so walked out and rudeness on the phone. I have had the Oysters Rockefeller from the fish store and have heard they have a great chef. I just can not get past the rudeness of the management. I have decided to give up dining there. I feel they have a preferred crowd. The "In Crowd". Screw that.

nagol hnsamsvtra

This restaurant never disappoints. great bar scene and live music in the evenings. They make awesome reasonably priced muddled fruit martinis. Also a must try is their bacon wrapped olives and cheese martini. The seafood is always super fresh (they get it right form their own seafood store) pleasant unpretentious atmosphere and the best fried calamari (asian) I ever had.

Mark Buonagura

Never had a bad meal there. Happy hour rocks, 2$ off drinks and 4$ food specials. Service is very good. They also have food for the vegatarians. I has a bar that is cozy. It has a restaurant area that has enough tables to handle the crowd that comes for the good food. It has a great selection of seafood at the counter. A winner.

Russell Clinton

WOW I must have hit the wrong night. I ordered rare steak tibits, they came very overdone. I had grilled shrimp (3 small) way overcooked..like eating rubber ($12.95). hamburger was ordered medium..I got a hocky puck. Some prices are crazy...Fettuccine..with chicken is $22.95 !!!!

Pete Guido

Decided to try something different. First time here. Goose dirty martinis w/blue cheese olives...awesome! Service at the bar was excellent. Food A+. Got the fish taco app and coconut crusted talapia. Cant forget the Asian calamari. We will be back.

Michael Platt

Lots of seafood options, large servings. My wife got the fish tacos which were the best. Lobster bisque was out of this world. Live music on Friday nights. Not for those looking for a quiet spot. So good!

Jaclyn Incorvia Corrigan

My family has gotten their prepared coconut or almond crusted fishes to go many times and all have been delicious. I have eaten in and service is fast and courteous, seafood tastes fresh and tasty!

Jhon Smith

Went there twice so far. Service is great and food awesome. I definitely recommend Oceans 5 ... Service was good both times, lunch and dinner. The decor looks like from the city ... Like it ..

Al Monteleone

Nice place with good and really fresh seafood. Was a bit under staffed but found out a wait person call in. Will try it again, maybe they can earn the fifth star

Brandon Smith

Food is good. Bar is great! I didnt like to hear that my shrimp was cooked in the microwave by the waitress. Other than that it would have been 5 stars!

Melissa McGrath

Food is great most of the time. Its a nice local spot. There are times when waiter service is not at its best though.

YU ER

This is one of the best seafood restaurants Ive ever eaten in. Great ambiance and the freshest seafood!

Jonathan Keen

Great specials and fresh fish. A nice place to get an affordable fish dinner on Long Island.

Michael Smith

Great food and low key atmosphere. Friendly staff with moderate pricing.

Ed OConnell

Great shrimp cocktail and every thing Ive tried has been amazing. A +

Peter Christopher

Great food. Great service. Great place to hang out and have a drink.